VxWorks vs VxWorks.bin: Understanding the Key Differences

Table of Contents

Understanding the Difference Between the Files VxWorks and VxWorks.bin

When developing or deploying systems based on VxWorks, it is common to encounter two similarly named files: VxWorks and VxWorks.bin. Because the filenames are almost identical, they are often assumed to be interchangeable. In reality, they represent different image formats, each serving a distinct role in the build, debug, and boot process.

This article explains what each file is, how they are related, and when you should use one versus the other.

🧭 Introduction
#

In a typical VxWorks BSP build, the kernel is produced in more than one form. These forms exist to satisfy different requirements:

Rich visibility during development and debugging
Simplicity and robustness during booting and deployment

Understanding the difference between VxWorks and VxWorks.bin helps avoid common boot issues and makes debugging far more effective.

📦 What Is the `VxWorks` File?
#

The file named VxWorks is usually the primary kernel build output generated by the VxWorks build system for a specific BSP.

Depending on the architecture and toolchain, this file is typically:

An ELF-format executable
A symbol-rich image
A structured file containing headers, sections, and metadata

Because of these properties, VxWorks is mainly used during development and debugging.

Key characteristics of `VxWorks`
#

Contains full symbol information (unless explicitly stripped)
Preserves section layout such as .text, .data, and .bss
Can be loaded directly by debuggers or ELF-aware bootloaders
Enables source-level debugging and postmortem analysis

In most BSPs, all other image formats are derived from this file.

🧱 What Is the `VxWorks.bin` File?
#

The VxWorks.bin file is a raw binary image produced from the VxWorks executable.

It is typically created by:

Removing executable headers
Stripping metadata and symbol information
Flattening the image into a contiguous block of bytes

The result is a minimal image that contains only what must be placed in memory for the system to boot.

Key characteristics of `VxWorks.bin`
#

Raw binary data (no ELF headers)
Smaller footprint than VxWorks
Easy for simple bootloaders to load
Commonly used in production and manufacturing

Many embedded bootloaders cannot parse ELF files, making VxWorks.bin the preferred format for final deployment.

🔍 Key Differences at a Glance
#

Aspect	`VxWorks`	`VxWorks.bin`
File format	Executable (often ELF)	Raw binary
Headers & metadata	Present	Removed
Debug symbols	Often included	Not included
Typical usage	Development & debugging	Booting & deployment
Bootloader requirement	ELF-aware loader	Simple binary loader

🔗 How the Two Files Are Related
#

The relationship between the two images is straightforward:

VxWorks.bin is generated from VxWorks.

A typical workflow looks like this:

Configure the BSP and kernel components
Build the VxWorks kernel
Generate the VxWorks executable
Convert or strip it to produce VxWorks.bin

Any change to kernel configuration, components, or BSP code requires rebuilding VxWorks, which in turn produces a new VxWorks.bin.

🚀 Role in the Boot Process
#

Which file is used depends largely on the bootloader design:

Development bootloaders or advanced loaders may load the VxWorks ELF file directly
ROM-based or lightweight bootloaders usually expect VxWorks.bin

Common scenarios include:

TFTP boot during development using VxWorks
Flash programming for production using VxWorks.bin

Although both files boot the same operating system, they take different paths to get there.

🧠 Why Both Files Exist
#

Maintaining both formats serves practical engineering needs:

VxWorks prioritizes visibility, symbols, and debugging
VxWorks.bin prioritizes simplicity, size, and reliability

This separation allows efficient bring-up and debugging without compromising production robustness.

⚠️ Common Sources of Confusion
#

Typical mistakes include:

Treating VxWorks and VxWorks.bin as interchangeable
Flashing an ELF-format image into a bootloader that expects raw binary
Debugging a deployed issue without the matching VxWorks symbol file

A recommended best practice is to keep both files from the same build together, ensuring symbols always match the deployed binary.

✅ Summary
#

In summary:

VxWorks is a symbol-rich, executable kernel image used mainly for development
VxWorks.bin is a stripped, raw binary image used for booting and deployment
Both represent the same VxWorks system in different formats
The correct choice depends on your bootloader and development stage

Understanding this distinction leads to smoother bring-up, easier debugging, and more reliable VxWorks deployments.